Reviews & Links for "My Mother's Daughter"

By Alice Hartsuyker

A Review by Julianna Lower, Ithaca, NY

My Mother's Daughter presents a personal account of life in New York during the 1930's that is touching and real. Alice Hartsuyker puts in these narratives small details: sights, sounds, smells, and tastes, that give these vignettes their flavorful and gritty sense of time and place. The book as a whole is not so much a chronological autobiography, but rather a literary scrapbook of a girl's life, and her reflections and stories about her mother. The stories reveal a relationship that is at times poignant, loving, fearful, admiring, and enigmatic; in short, the quintessentially complicated nature of this very special bond between mother and daughter.

The determination of Aileen (Alice Hartsuyker's mother), to raise three children as a single parent during a time when raising children with two parents was difficult enough, is a testament to the strength of women during that time, or just of one remarkable lady. Regardless, Aileen's attitudes, superstitions, and fierce love of her children render her distinct, as described by Alice throughout these stories.

Moreover, the book is liberally peppered with historical photographs of various parts of the neighborhood, of people and places similar to those described in the book, and of the family itself. As if the dynamic prose and compelling tapestry of the stories weren't enough, the pictures help the reader truly grasp the sense of reality.

My Mother's Daughter is a wonderful mix of struggle and triumph, myth, truth, and tall tale enough to saturate the imagination. I highly recommend it.


A Review by Pearl Silvernale, Colorado Springs, CO.

Alice's former writing teacher

Reminiscences of childhood rarely involve the reader to the extent that does this well-written memoir of a young girl growing up on the Lower East Side of New York of the 1930's.

With accurate and careful attention to detail, Alice Hartsuyker brings us into the family she honors with wit, charm and love as they experience the rich ethnic mix of the era.

"My Mother's Daughter" is a valuable historical account of a time and place many will identify with as well as providing a glimpse into and longing for our own childhood. A beautiful book you will cherish, read and re-read.


Excerpts from a review by Don Harrison

Her mother was known as Aileen O'Mahony. It is the struggles, superstitions, adventures and high-spiritness of the O'Mahony clan that fills most of this richly sentimental memoir of Hartsuyker's life during the Depression years. Hartsuyker's memories of her aging, time-worn, and grimy immigrant neighborhood are suffused with pleasant recollections of the Yiddish culture which surrounded her and for which for awhile even include her as a "Shabbos Goy". For Jewish readers, these essays open a window upon Irish immigrant life through which we can also see a mirror in which our own immigrant roots are reflected. We come away from the book convinced that whatever trauma her mother's marriage had suffered she did a remarkably good job raising her children. This book of warm essays is well worth having.

The original review can be found in its full context on the blog called "Jewish Sightseeing".





Visit to Henry Street Settlement

On April 13, 2005 Alice visited the Henry Street Settlement, a place that figures so promenently in a number of the stories found in "My Mother's Daughter".  During that visit she was able to give a broader historical picture to the staff of this fine institution.  Follow the link below for a more detailed description of this visit, along with a photo album compiled by the staff from that day

Visit to Henry Street Settlement